Top 10 Crib Mattress Protectors Reviewed in 2019

If you’re the parent of a new baby or multiple children. you are probably all too familiar with the need of the top crib mattress protector. From leaky diapers to spit-up messes, your baby’s mattress needs to have a barrier on it. Plus, a thin sheet placed over the top of a mattress isn’t very comfortable. crib mattress protectors provide a level of padding and comfort for your little one.

So, how do you fix this issue? You use a crib mattress protector. There are many different brands, styles, and types. It can be daunting trying to find the perfect one. We know how special your little one is to you and how you want him or her to have the best of the best baby care products. So, we decided to help you out by searching Amazon for the top 10 best crib mattress protectors that we could find.

Each of these protectors has rave reviews and high star ratings. On our list, you’ll see brands like American Baby Company and SureGuard. We want you to feel confident in our picks so we’ve made sure to include brands that you are familiar with.

Are you ready to find the best baby crib mattress protectors that money can buy? Great! Grab your rattles and let’s go!
[toc]

10. Utopia Bedding Waterproof Crib Mattress Protector

Utopia Bedding Waterproof Crib Fitted Mattress Protector (Pack of 2) -...
  • CRIB MATTRESS PROTECTOR PACK - Pack of 2 crib mattress protectors that fits easily on most of the cribs of standard size...
  • PERFECT FIT - 7 Inches deep skirts provide the perfect fit and protection to all sides (except bottom)
  • SOFT AND BREATHABLE - Quilted cloth top is super soft, luxurious, highly breathable and super absorbent

This crib mattress protector comes in either a 1 or 2 pack. This listing is for a 2 pack. These protectors fit easily and work for most standard size cribs. They measure 27 by 52 by 8 inches.

Here is a message from the company, “The premium quality material with 8-inch deep skirts ensures a perfect fit to all sides except for the bottom. The top layer of the mattress is made of an ultra-soft material that’s crafted with baby’s skin sensitivity in mind. Have the little ones go to a good night’s sleep without being discomforted at any point and time. The protector is thin enough to keep the baby safe and protected at all times and warm enough to give it an extra layer between the mattress and sheet. Also, it’s highly breathable elasticized fabric makes the fabric fit the mattress with great ease without the need to fight its way on”.

Pros

  • Made from ultra-soft material
  • Machine washable
  • Comes with explicit care instructions

Cons

  • Some complaints about the product being cheaply made

Check Price


9. Masirs Crib Mattress Protector Cover

Crib Mattress Protector Cover - Comfortable, Breathable and Waterproof...
  • WATERPROOF: Rest assured knowing your crib mattress is well protected from any liquids.
  • ULTRA-SOFT: Made from bamboo rayon terry fabric for a comfortable feel and superior performance.
  • BREATHABLE: Bamboo textile keeps your baby warm in the winter without being hot and sweaty in the summer.

Allow your baby to sleep in comfort and yourself to have peace of mind with you choose Masirs crib covers. The cover is completely waterproof and keeps your baby’s mattress safe from all liquids.

Here is a note from the manufacturer, “Rest assured knowing your little one is snug and comfy in his crib. Masir’s ultra-soft crib mattress protector is made from bamboo rayon terry fabric for superior quality and performance. It is both breathable and waterproof, so your baby remains comfortable while his crib mattress is well protected. You no longer need to worry about leaking diapers or dripping bottles; the bamboo fabric is superior in its ability to absorb the liquid. This excellent textile is also breathable, so your baby will stay warm in the winter without sweating in the summer. This crib mattress protector will also block out dust mites and prevent mold. This is an extremely important factor for those who suffer from allergies, and for babies and young children who are more sensitive. Designed to withstand constant use, the crib mattress protector is stain resistant as well as being machine washable and dryer friendly. Keep your crib mattress clean and protected while giving your baby a cozy and restful night’s sleep”.

Pros

  • Made from super-soft material
  • Breathable fabric
  • Stain resistant and machine washable

Cons

  • Some reports from verified users saying this product doesn’t handle machine drying very well

Check Price


8. Margaux & May Ultra Soft Waterproof Crib Mattress

Crib Mattress Protector Pad (Mom's Choice Award Winner) - by Margaux &...
  • 🏆 WINNER OF THE PRESTIGIOUS MOM’S CHOICE AWARD for Crib Mattress Protector in 2020. TRUSTED; Most crib mattress...
  • PLUSH NOISELESS MATERIALS: The first thing most of our customers notice is how soft and quiet our crib mattress...
  • AWARD WINNING 4 LAYERED ULTRA WATERPROOF AND DURABLE: Our crib mattress protector is breathable, waterproof and washes...

You’ll love how reliable this mattress protector is as it is 100% waterproof. It’s very durable but also quite soft and comfortable. Your little one will have a great night’s rest with this mattress protector underneath him or her.

Check out what the manufacturer has to say, “SIZE: 28 x 52 x 9 inches. We have listened to our customer’s feedback and have increased the size of the skirt to make it even easier to secure on your crib mattress. The elasticized fabric makes the protector fit the mattress snugly, but it’s not too tight so that you feel like you’re fighting the mattress every time you take the protector off and put it on. The crib mattress protector is snug for safety reasons and should not be loose over the crib mattress. It is easy to take off and wash”.

Pros

  • Highly absorbent, durable, and breathable
  • Made from bamboo rayon fibers
  • White in color so it is discreet when a sheet is placed on top

Cons

  • A few users reported that the waterproof packing begins to detach from the other material

Check Price


7. COZYCUDDLES Premium Zippered Quilted Waterproof

COZYCUDDLES Premium Zippered Quilted Waterproof Crib Protector Cover -...
  • ✅ PROTECT YOUR BABY - CozyCuddles fully encased crib mattress protector is supported with a 360-degree zipper to fully...
  • ✅ PROTECT YOUR MATTRESS - CozyCuddles offers a multi-layer crib mattress protector waterproof which is designed to...
  • ✅ SKIN FRIENDLY FABRICS - Our high-quality fabric is made from soft, breathable and hypoallergenic materials which...

We really like the zippered design of these crib mattress protectors. They are very easy to put on the mattress as well as to take off. Your baby’s mattress will be safe from liquids, spills, and even dust.

According to the manufacturer, “CozyCuddles fully encased crib mattress protector is supported with a 360-degree zipper to fully protect your baby from dust-mites and bed-bugs which can nest inside bedding and cause harm to a baby’s sensitive skin. STUDIES REVEALED that by protecting your mattress from dust mites and bed-bugs using HYPOALLERGENIC materials, you reduce the risk of asthma for your baby”.

Pros

  • Made from skin-friendly fabrics
  • Comes with a special gift – waterproof baby pillow protector
  • 100% lifetime warranty and money back guarantee

Cons

  • Can only be air-dried

Check Price


6. Sealy Waterproof Fitted Crib/Toddler Mattress Pad Cover

No products found.

This mattress pad can be used as a protective barrier on both crib and toddler bed mattresses. It offers 100% waterproof protection. No worries about leaky messes getting through this cover! It is by the Sealy brand, so you know it it is bound to be amazing.

Here is what the company has to say, “The Sealy Waterproof Crib Mattress Pads protect baby’s crib mattress from moisture and come in a convenient 2-pack value. The 100% waterproof barrier protects crib and toddler mattresses from leaky messes and spills for a more sanitary sleeping environment, while the soft knit top and hypoallergenic quilted filling offer superior absorbency and cozy comfort. A SecureStay fitted stretch skirt wraps underneath the mattress for safety and has elasticized edges to hold the pad securely in place. This value pack has 2 identical pads, so baby’s mattress is always protected when the other pad is in the wash. These easy-clean pads are machine washable and dryer friendly and measure 52” x 28” to perfectly fit USA standard size crib and toddler bed mattresses”.

Pros

  • 100% waterproof barrier
  • Machine washable and dryer friendly
  • Passes all safety standards and wash testing

Cons

  • Some concerns over whether the sides of the protector will hold up over the long term as they are very taut on the mattress

No products found.


5. Carters Waterproof Fitted Quilted Crib and Toddler Pad

Carters Waterproof Fitted Quilted Crib and Toddler Protective Mattress...
  • Fabrics are 100% Polyester
  • Solid White
  • Fits a Standard Size Crib Mattress 28" x 52"

Carter’s is a leader in baby care products and this crib mattress protector is no exception. It is made from 100% polyester fabric that is breathable and soft. It is also highly resistant to fluids.

This protector fits any standard-sized crib mattress that measures 28″ x 52″.

You can easily machine wash this protector and dry it in the machine, too.

Pros

  • Crisp and clean white color
  • Can be machine laundered
  • Extremely absorbent

Cons

  • Some reports of the mattress pad being thin

Check Price


4. HIPPIH Crib Mattress Protector

This mattress protector is amazing! It’s made from skin-friendly material and is virtually noiseless. Who wants their baby to be awoken by moving around on a  crinkly mattress pad? The materials in the fabric are premium polyester and hypoallergenic fibers. They are also extra soft to the touch.

Check out what the manufacturer has to say, “100% WATERPROOF & DURABLE: HIPPIH breathable crib mattress protector made with TPU membrane in the backing protects again urine, infant’s saliva and daily accidents on the mattress, the mattress won’t be mildewed, prevent the breeding of bacterium. Easy on and off, won’t slide with an elastic band round, measures 52 x 28 x 9 inch. Hypoallergenic mattress cover protects again dust mites, allergens, bacteria, mildew, and mold, creating a healthy sleeping environment for your baby. Perfect for those unexpected leaky nights”.

Pros

  • Hypoallergenic material
  • Machine washable
  • Perfect after-sale protection

Cons

  • Some complaints of the pad not being very thick

3. Jambini Fully Encased Crib Mattress Cover

Jambini Zipper Crib Mattress Protector - Fully Encased & Waterproof...
  • ALLERGY-FRIENDLY MATERIALS:Our mattress protector is completely hypoallergenic and encases your entire mattress...
  • NOISE-FREE: This premium encasement was built to prevent any noise caused by movement, allowing your child to get a...
  • Its layer of soft padding gives your baby extra comfort at night for an even cozier sleep

For your little one, they can be sleeping on this highly-absorbent crib mattress pad. The extra layer of soft padding gives your little one a comfortable place to rest his or her little head at night.

Take a look at what the manufacturer has to say, “Safety Baby waterproof crib mattress cover – zippered encasement. Amazon users say: “my favorite thing about this specific mattress cover is that it zips around the mattress so that both top and bottom are covered, this prevents the mattress cover from curling up over the corners or sliding off of the mattress.” and “the cover was easy to put on, in fact, easier than the stretch ones that just go over the top”. Built to last, this high-quality mattress protector has the ability to withstand hundreds of washer/dryer cycles without any shrinkage so you can relax knowing you are getting great value. Never be worried about leaks, dust mites, allergens, mold or bacteria. Provides all the benefits of a waterproof liner without the annoying crinkly sound”.

Pros

  • Premium encasement keeps the mattress pad noise-free
  • Completely hypoallergenic
  • No vinyl, PVC, phthalates, fire-retardants, and other toxins

Cons

  • Zipper sometimes gets stuck
  • Not a great choice for mega-urine leaks

Check Price


2. Swaddlez Crib Mattress Protector

This crib mattress protector by the Swaddlez company is made from super soft material. Just as your baby’s skin is soft and delicate, so should their bedding be. The material used is from bamboo viscose, which also keeps your mattress clean and fresh.

Here is what the manufacturer has to say about the super absorbency of the pad, “The no worry solution for those leaky bottle messes or potty training misses. Bamboo Viscose is considered one of the most absorbent textiles available”.

Pros

  • Highly breathable material
  • Made to fit
  • 100% customer satisfaction guarantee

Cons

  • There have been a few reports of the inside of the pad tearing after a short period of time

1. SureGuard Mattress Protectors Crib Size

SureGuard Crib Size Mattress Protector - 100% Waterproof,...
  • 100% Waterproof - Top protection against everyday liquids and stains; 10-year quality guarantee - Great baby registry...
  • Hypoallergenic - Blocks dust mites, allergens, bacteria, mildew and mold - For bed bug protection, buy together with a...
  • Soft & Noiseless - 100% cotton terry surface; Wicks away moisture; Retains the feel of your child's mattress - Free from...

We love this mattress pad because it is available for not just cribs but a variety of mattresses.  The pad is made from cotton and is 100% waterproof. This product comes with a 10-year quality guarantee.

Here is a message from the company, “Hypoallergenic – Blocks dust mites, allergens, bacteria, mildew, and mold – For bed bug protection, buy together with a SureGuard Mattress Encasement. Soft & Noiseless – 100% cotton terry surface; Wicks away moisture; Retains the feel of your child’s mattress – Free from Vinyl, PVC, Phthalates, fire retardants, and other toxic chemicals”.

Pros

  • Durable and easy to clean
  • Greenguard Gold certified
  • Hypoallergenic

Cons

  • Some complaints about the waterproof efficacy for kids who have heavy urine accidents

Check Price

Why We Chose SureGuard Mattress Protectors Crib Size As Our Top Choice…

Choosing a great mattress pad protector for your child’s crib is a big decision. For one, you want to ensure your child’s comfort but you also want to secure the integrity of the mattress. We hope this list has provided you with some valuable insight.

We fully stand behind all of the products on this list as each one has gotten rave reviews and high star ratings on Amazon. However, we had to choose just one for our #1 spot.

We decided to go with the SureGuard Mattress Protectors Crib Size. This mattress pad has gotten over 5k reviews and holds almost a 5-star rating. The fabric is made from hypoallergenic material that you can feel safe laying your baby down on. Plus, there aren’t any harmful chemicals in the material. It’s soft and absorbent.

Have you decided which crib mattress pad you’ll be purchasing, today? We highly recommend our top choice, but any product from this list will be excellent.

As you prepare to check out, be sure to click on the yellow Amazon button for a safe and secure checkout experience.